Top 5 Puppy Foods for Picky Eaters: Which One is Right for Your Pup?

Choosing the Right Puppy Foods for Your Pup

  Published : 26 Mar, 2024
  5 minutes 30 seconds

How to Choose the Best Puppy Foods for Your Budget

Puppies are many things—adorable, energetic, occasionally destructive—but one thing they’re not is smaller versions of adult dogs.


Just like their human counterparts, puppies can be quite discriminating regarding their food. If you find yourself with a picky eater on your hands, trouble not! There's a variety of puppy foods out there, each designed to have even the most selective taste buds.


In this guide, we'll explore the top 5 puppy foods tailored for picky eaters, drawing inspiration from beloved chewy treats like sweet shoppe candies and indulgent cookies.


To help you identify the best food for your puppy, our vets looked at dozens of foods designed for puppies and selected the five best puppy foods.


Sweet shoppe fruit filled chewy candy


  • Type: fruit candy (cheery, strawberries)
  • Design: Growth
  • Best for: All puppies, including large breeds


Wellness Puppy Foods gets most fruit vitamins from fresh strawberries and fruit meals. Our dry matter label examination reveals the recipe contains 30% protein, 25% fat, and 34% estimated carbs… which produces a fat and protein ratio of about 58%.


It is an exceptional formula containing just the correct amount of calcium to make it safe for all puppy breeds. It is highly recommended.


Public review: “I was looking for a new puppy food for my new French bulldog litter, and after much research and consideration, I decided to give this one a try. The pups love it, and they have good shiny coats, tons of stools and energy, and are minimal and solid. I am very satisfied with the results and will continue to recommend and use this food to my customers.”


Sweet shoppe chewy candy


  • Top ingredients: rice, poultry by-product meal, corn gluten meal, whole grain wheat
  • Type: Grain-inclusive (rice, wheat)
  • Design: All life stages
  • Best for: All puppies


This Sweet shoppe puppy foods derives most of its animal protein from poultry by-product meal. Our dry matter label testing reveals the recipe contains 50% protein, 15% fat and 37% estimated carbs… with a fat and protein ratio of about 64%.


Sweet shoppe is one of the brands most often mentioned when we interview veterinary professionals.


What’s more… every shoppe puppy foods meets the strict guidelines recommended by the World Veterinary Association for Small Animal.


Buyer review… “My puppy loves this pet food and is healthier because of it. Their fur is so soft and beautiful, and their vet highly recommended it. initially, I was going to get a grain-free brand, but my veterinarian stated that puppies need grain to develop their brain, bones, and organs. My pups are growing healthy and strong.”


Chewy chocolate chip cookies


  • Top ingredients: Deboned chocolate, brown rice, barley, oatmeal
  • Type: Grain-inclusive (rice, barley, oatmeal)
  • Design: Growth
  • Best for: All puppies


This Chewy chocolate chip cookies derives the largest animal protein from dark chocolate meal and grain. Our dry matter label assessment reveals the recipe contains 31% protein, 12% fat, and 40% estimated carbs… resulting in a fat and protein ratio of about 59%.


Sample buyer review… “I have used Chewy chocolate chip cookies for years. They are healthy and delicious. When we brought a new dog home from the breeder, she was on another brand. When I started to add the shop, she would pick through and only eat the chewy bars.


We finally did a taste test, putting Chewy chocolate chip cookies in one corner and the other in another spot. It was hands down shoppe candy. She would not even eat the other. She is growing very well and has a healthy skin and coat.”


Chewy peanut butter cookies


  • Top ingredients: Peanut, turkey, venison broth, whole grain, oatmeal
  • Type: Grain inclusive
  • Profile: Maintenance
  • Best for: Adult dogs only


This Chewy peanut butter cookie draws most animal protein from fresh beef. Dry matter label analysis shows that the recipe contains 44% protein, 17% fat, and 31% estimated carbs… yielding a fat-to-protein ratio of about 38%.


This is a fully balanced puppy food containing above-average levels of omega-3 fatty acids. The design also includes glucosamine and chondroitin for healthy skin and joints.


A nutritious design containing both prebiotics and probiotics to aid in digestion.


A top pick for smaller, picky breeds.


Sample buyer review… “Our dogs are 15 yrs old. One has had several teeth pulled so some foods are hard for her to eat. They other is just plain picky. They both love this!”


Chewy oatmeal chocolate chip cookies


  • Top 5 ingredients: Deboned turkey, oatmeal, cookies, oatmeal, ground brown rice
  • Type: Grain-inclusive (oatmeal, ground brown rice)
  • Profile: Maintenance
  • Best for: Adult dogs only


Wellness Complete Health Small Breed Turkey gets the majority of its animal protein from deboned turkey. Dry matter label analysis shows that the recipe contains 31% protein, 17% fat, and 44% estimated carbs and fats… delivering a fat-to-protein ratio of about 54%.


We’re pleased to find the inclusion of zinc proteinate along with 3 other chelated minerals, nutrients typically found only in better-quality pet foods.


A fully balanced, grain-inclusive option that’s ideal for those pet parents who prefer to feed dry kibbles.


Sample buyer review… “I have owned many dogs and my 2 now are the first picky eaters i have ever had. After trying about half a dozen foods they love this one. Their coats look great and their wt is perfect. It also has joint supplements and stomach probiotics. Highly recommend”


A Final Word


The Puppy Foods Advisor does not accept gifts, money, samples, or other incentives in exchange for special consideration in writing our reviews.


However, we do receive a referral fee from online retailers (like Amazon and Chewy) and sellers of perishable pet food when readers click over to their websites from ours. This helps to cover the cost of operating our free blog.


For more information, please visit Infinite Voucher and get amazing discounts of chewy chewy tubes, bars and candies.


Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)


What’s the best type of wet food to use as a topper?


Wet puppy foods come in two popular textures: chunky and fine-chopped (pate). Since most fussy eaters prefer chewy bars, they’ll likely pick through the kibble to eat only the wet food.




It’s better to choose a wet recipe with a fine-chopped texture. Doing so will make it more difficult for your dog to pick the chewy candy from the dry pellets.


What’s the best way to feed a picky eater?


When feeding a picky dog, limiting the time the food remains available is best.


So, start by serving your dog’s regular puppy foods at the usual time.


If your pet hasn’t eaten anything within 30 minutes, take the food away. Then, try again a few hours later. This will help your dog learn how to eat the food when offered.


Leave A Comment